Case Study : Priya Sharma, Order Defect Rate (ODR) Suspension

Learn how Priya Sharma resolved her Amazon seller account suspension due to high Order Defect Rate (ODR) issues caused by negative feedback, high return rates, and A-to-Z claims. A detailed case study on effective reinstatement strategies and preventive actions.

Order Defect Rate (ODR) Suspension:

Client Name: Priya Sharma
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra

Case Overview:
Priya Sharma, an Amazon seller specializing in home appliances, faced account suspension due to a high Order Defect Rate (ODR) exceeding Amazon's threshold of 1%. The suspension was driven by:

  1. High Return Rates: Multiple returns attributed to defective items or unmet customer expectations.

  2. Negative Feedback: 15% of customers left 1-star reviews citing issues with product quality and delayed delivery.

  3. A-to-Z Claims: Several claims were filed by buyers seeking refunds, alleging non-receipt or poor product quality.

Challenges Identified:

  • Root Cause: A supplier's inconsistent quality control caused product defects.

  • Lack of Communication: Delays in responding to customer complaints escalated issues to A-to-Z claims.

  • Operational Errors: Late shipments and tracking errors further increased customer dissatisfaction.

Steps Taken:

1. Root Cause Analysis:

  • Reviewed all affected orders to identify patterns in returns and complaints.

  • Conducted supplier audits to ensure product compliance with quality standards.

2. Corrective Actions:

  • Supplier Management: Replaced underperforming suppliers and implemented stricter quality checks.

  • Inventory Updates: Removed defective stock from fulfillment centers.

  • Shipping Improvements: Streamlined logistics processes to ensure timely delivery.

3. Proactive Customer Engagement:

  • Reached out to affected customers with apologies and compensation (discounts/refunds).

  • Addressed negative feedback by offering resolutions to dissatisfied buyers.

4. Preventive Actions:

  • Enhanced product listing descriptions to set clear customer expectations.

  • Implemented a customer service protocol to resolve issues within 24 hours.

  • Enabled proactive notifications to buyers for shipment tracking and delays.

Plan of Action (POA):

The following POA was submitted to Amazon for reinstatement:

  1. Acknowledgment: Priya acknowledged responsibility for high ODR and explained root causes.

  2. Corrective Measures: Detailed steps to resolve past defects, improve quality, and enhance delivery timelines.

  3. Preventive Steps: Outlined long-term measures to maintain an ODR below 1%.

  4. Commitment: Provided assurance of compliance with Amazon’s seller performance standards.

Outcome:

  • Account Reinstated: Within 5 days of submitting the POA, Priya’s account was reinstated.

  • ODR Improvement: Reduced ODR to 0.5% by maintaining higher quality standards and proactive customer service.

  • Sales Growth: Regained buyer trust, achieving a 20% increase in monthly sales.

Client Testimonial:

"The reinstatement process felt daunting, but the team’s expert guidance ensured my account was restored quickly. I’ve learned to manage quality and customer relations better, ensuring a seamless experience for buyers."